When I was pregnant, someone asked me whether or not we would use a pacifier with our baby. I panicked, because I hadn't thought of that yet. I had planned out my diaper system, sorted and folded and washed and resorted all the white or neutral colored baby clothes, scoured the baby name book and done prenatal yoga every day in my 3rd trimester, but I hadn't worked out my stance on the pacifier yet.
So I went through the baby books and tried to decide what we would do with our baby. Pacifier? No. Formula? Definitely no. Early potty training? No. Cloth Diapers? Only if they're not too much trouble. Feeding on demand? Yes. Sleep training? No.
It all seemed so easy, so black and white. As if parenting choices could be turned into a multiple-choice exam, with bubble sheets to fill in with pencil and nice, crisp boundaries around each question.
As it turned out, it was not so black and white. We didn't use a pacifier for the first 10 weeks or so, but we did let Bea suck on our pinky fingers instead. How is that different? I don't know, except that my pinky finger is attached to my arm, which then had to dangle out of bed while she sucked on it, and I had to very carefully try to extract my finger from her mouth without waking her up so that I could fall asleep. When we finally gave her a pacifier, she went "glurmp!" and sucked away happily. I remember thinking, "wow, that thing works!" Now I can't even remember why I didn't want to give her one in the first place. I think it had something to do with seeing 5 year olds running around with pacifiers in their mouths, but perhaps that wouldn't have happened anyway. She gave up the pacifier herself around 6 months.
There have been many, many other decisions along the parenting road that I have made differently than I would have predicted when I was a mom-to-be. I have let her cry, not for hours at a time, but if she's playing around at bedtime sometimes she will have five or ten minutes by herself in the crib to think about why falling asleep is a good idea. We were not as careful about introducing solids as I would have thought we would be. I had imagined myself happily breastfeeding on demand through the second year, despite odd looks or toddler gymnastics, totally committed to doing the best thing for my baby's health and emotional well-being.
And here I am, weaning at 15 months.
The next time around, I will be more careful about judging others or saying "oh, I would never do that". Even if what they are doing seems uncaring, or lazy, or odd, there is no way to predict exactly what you will need to do for your own health and well-being as a parent, and no way to turn the glorious technicolor human experience of raising a child into yes and no tickboxes.